Press Review
US press review by Paul Melcher

Kansas City Star : Dazed victims wait for help at the scene of an explosion and 4-alarm fire at JJ's restaurant on The Country Club Plaza on Tuesday, Feb. 19, 2013. Photo by Bob Greenspan//Special to The Star

New Yorker Magazine : In the summer of 2010, Jonas Unger was commissioned by ZEITmagazin to photograph Gérard Depardieu at his château in the Loire Valley.

NBCnews: Thousands of Thai Buddhist monks chant during a lantern lighting to celebrate Makha Bucha day at Dhammakaya Temple in Pathum Thani province, on the outskirts of Bangkok, Thailand, Feb. 25, 2013.Rungroj Yongrit / EPA

LA Times : Jennifer Hudson waits for her entrance cue at the Academy Awards PHOTOGRAPH BY: AL SEIB / LOS ANGELES TIMES

Palm Beach Post : FEBRUARY 26: Kushti wrestlers warm up before their daily training session, at a wrestling club in Lahore, Pakistan. Kushti, an Indo-Pakistani form of wrestling, is several thousand years old and is a national sport in the country. (Muhammed Muheisen/Associated Press)

Denver Post : In this Thursday, Aug. 2, 2012, photo, Pakistani Kawthar Javaid, 42, who was injured by a remote control bomb in Faisalabad in 2005, poses for a picture in Rawalpindi, Pakistan. Hazratullah Khan's right leg was amputated below the knee after he survived a car bombing as he was on his way home from school. His response when asked whether peace talks should be held with the Taliban leaders who ordered attacks like the ones that maimed him is simple: Hang them alive. Slice their flesh off their bodies and cut them into pieces. (AP Photo/Muhammed Muheisen)

Mercury news : A sea lion swims through its basin on Feb. 25, 2013, at the zoo in Frankfurt am Main, Germany. (Nicolas Armer/AFP

National Geographic : Photograph by Jason van der Valk, A large vessel makes her way through the Juan de Fuca Strait near Victoria, British Columbia, on the southern shores of Vancouver Island.

Boston Globe : Around 2,000 people make snow angels at the University of Minnesota Duluth on February 9, 2013, in Duluth, Minn. The event was held to try to break the world record of 8,962 snow angels in one area set in 2007 in Bismarck, N.D. (Clint Austin/The Duluth News-Tribune)

NY Mag: Parade Photo: Nadia Lee Cohen.The 22-year-old photographer Nadia Lee Cohen may still be in her last year of school at London College of Fashion, but that hasn’t stopped her from already receiving noteworthy accolades, including the Taylor Wessing Prize at the National Portrait Gallery.

Slate.com : Raid on the White Tiger Regiment, 1971. © Zhang Yaxin/Courtesy see+ Gallery, Beijing, and Stephen Bulger Gallery, Toronto. Photographer Zhang Yaxin was one of the only people in China with access to color film during the Chinese Cultural Revolution (1966-76). Zhang was a photographer for Xinhua News Agency when he was chosen by Jiang Qing, the wife of Chairman Mao Zedong, to photograph the performances of the model operas she developed after the Communist Party leaders banned traditional Peking opera for being too bourgeois.
Kansas City Star : Dazed victims wait for help at the scene of an explosion and 4-alarm fire at JJ's restaurant on The Country Club Plaza on Tuesday, Feb. 19, 2013. Photo by Bob Greenspan//Special to The Star
Whenever we find ourselves in a troubling situation, as a witness, we intervene. We either get physically involved or call for rescue, but either way, we do not remain passive. Photographers - photojournalists in particular- do the same, but not in the same way.
Lately, the actions of photojournalists witnessing troublesome situations, have been, yet again, put into question. Instead of intervening in some manner or the other, photojournalists tend to continue to photograph, making some people upset. What they do not understand is that, unlike you and me, photojournalist intervention happened via their photography. They do not ignore the situation, dismiss it or walk away from it. They intervene very actively, by taking pictures. For them, it is their most powerful weapon. Not their fists, not their yells, not their posturing, but their camera and storytelling skills. A photojournalist that does not intervene is a photojournalist that doesn’t take any picture.
Sure, our laws, based on our cultural senses, tells us that the first priority is to bring assistance to a person in danger. To immediately try to alter the course of events. We do so by physically getting involved and/or call for help. While the physical approach is the most immediate, it can have dire consequences for everyone. Calling for help, wether using a phone or our lungs, is the most frequent option chosen by witnesses. And what is it besides making others aware of the situation? Isn’t that what a photojournalist does ? Screams for help with his images ? Thus can we really say that the photographer seeming inaction is not an act of social cowardice but rather, it is the most unselfish action taken.
By choosing not to intervene but reporting, calling/screaming for social awareness over what they witness, photojournalist might actually be doing a better job at intervening than the rest of us. They can actually prevent for the same situation to happen again, not only to those he has witnessed but to others all over the world.
There is no cruelty in the photographers eye when he photographs scenes of incredible cruelty and inhumanity. In fact, there is compassion and a heighten sense of social responsibility. It is via their images that the situation can be resolved not once, but forever.
Their role is not to be a superhero seeking to rescue every single victim. These are for the all volunteer policemen, firefighters, military. The photojournalist is a reporter who’s role is to prevent our society from creating more victims, one photograph at a time.
Paul Melcher
Links
Contributors
Paul Melcher
